The government says the proposed laws will transform India's criminal justice system. Experts are sceptical.
Last week, India's ruling government unveiled three new bills in parliament, stating that they would usher in a "significant transformation in our criminal justice system".
The bills are crafted to abolish and replace a trio of criminal laws. The Indian Penal Code and the Indian Evidence Act are antiquated colonial-era laws, while the Code of Criminal Procedure is half a century old. The bills have been referred to a parliamentary committee for further debate. Home Minister Amit Shah says their objective is to "deliver justice, not mere punishment".
India's criminal justice system needs urgent reform: shoddy police investigations often result in catastrophic miscarriages of justice; jails overflow with undertrials and the slow moving courts are clogged with some 50 million cases.Legal scholars say the bills do contain some significant changes covering a swathe of the justice system.
For one, they bring offences like terrorism, corruption, mob lynching and organised crime under penal laws. They allow people to register a police complaint in any police station, regardless of the location where the crime took place. They propose video recording of search and seizure operations and increased use of electronic evidence and forensics during investigation. They introduce community service as a new form of punishment.
Yet, experts are sceptical about how some of these laws will work. Anup Surendranath, a professor of law at Delhi's National Law University, says the manner in which the new offences - acts endangering sovereignty, organised crime, mob lynching, terrorism, rape by false promise to marry - are drafted "continues to be so vague that it ends up giving the police unreasonably wide powers of arrest".
Belgique Dernières Nouvelles, Belgique Actualités
Similar News:Vous pouvez également lire des articles d'actualité similaires à celui-ci que nous avons collectés auprès d'autres sources d'information.
Mum-of-two on her musical journey from India to a new life in Northern IrelandClassically trained in Indian classical and folk music, Amita also writes and performs songs in Hindi and Kannada language.
Lire la suite »
Back to the future for India's rice farmersIndia, the world's biggest rice exporter, is turning to old varieties and new farming techniques.
Lire la suite »
First look inside the new M&S café after major changeThe Liverpool ONE store's new M&S 'café' has opened with a whole new look
Lire la suite »
India’s economic rise is not guaranteed\n\t\t\tLet our global subject matter experts broaden your perspective with timely insights and opinions you\n\t\t\tcan’t find anywhere else.\n\t\t
Lire la suite »
Data protection bill: Will India's hard-won information law get weaker?A crucial new law will make it hard to use the landmark right to information legislation, activists say.
Lire la suite »
Can India Inc extricate itself from China?Narendra Modi is testing a wide array of economic weapons
Lire la suite »